Fracking vs. Drilling: Containment Differences

May 23, 2024
Frac Tank Liner

What are the differences between facking vs. drilling? The exploration and extraction of hydrocarbons, such as oil and natural gas, are critical components of the global energy supply. Two prominent methods for extracting these resources are standard drilling and hydraulic fracturing, commonly known as fracking. These techniques not only differ in their operational approaches but also in how they manage and contain fluids during the extraction process.

Understanding the Differences: Drilling vs. Fracking

Standard Drilling is the traditional method of hydrocarbon extraction. It involves drilling a well vertically or, more recently, diagonally and horizontally, to reach an oil or gas reservoir. The process uses a drill bit to penetrate through the earth’s layers until it reaches the hydrocarbon-bearing formations. Once the reservoir is accessed, natural pressure forces the oil or gas to the surface, or pumps are used to extract the hydrocarbons.

Hydraulic Fracturing (Fracking), on the other hand, is a technique used to extract oil and gas from rock formations that are otherwise not easily permeable enough to yield these resources effectively. Fracking involves injecting a high-pressure fluid mixture into the rock formation to create fractures through which oil or gas can flow. This fluid typically consists of water, sand, and a mix of chemicals. The sand keeps the fractures open, allowing for the extraction of hydrocarbons trapped in the rock.

Fluids Management and Containment

The containment and management of fluids in both drilling and fracking are critical from both environmental and safety considerations, but the methods and challenges involved vary significantly.

In Standard Drilling, fluid management primarily revolves around handling various mixtures of drilling mud (a mixture of water, clay, and chemicals), used to lubricate the drill bit and stabilize the wellbore. The mud also serves to carry rock cuttings to the surface for analysis and disposal. Containment systems are designed to prevent leaks and spills, which could lead to environmental contamination. The used mud is often treated and recycled or disposed of in accordance with environmental regulations.

Drilling operations also involve the management of produced water, a byproduct which includes naturally occurring water from the geological formation that can be laden with minerals and hydrocarbons. This water is typically stored in on-site tanks before being treated, reused, or transported to disposal sites.

Fracking requires more complex fluid management strategies. The volume of water used in fracking is substantially higher than in standard drilling. The injected fluids are a mixture of water, chemicals, and proppants (such as sand, to keep the fracture open). Post-fracking, a significant portion of this fluid returns to the surface as flowback, which, along with produced water, must be managed carefully. These fluids can contain residual chemicals and must be treated as hazardous waste.

Containment in fracking operations is particularly challenging due to the potential for accidental spills or leaks and the risk of groundwater contamination. Therefore, fracking sites typically have robust containment measures such as double-lined frac pits or frac tanks to collect flowback water and produced water.

With more than 30 years of production and customization experience with impermeable geomembrane liners designed to hold fluids without leaking, Western Environmental Liner can boast significant expertise with the containment challenges of the drilling industry, for both standard drilling and fracking procedures. See our introduction to containment liners to get an idea of the solutions, and drill deeper (so to speak) in our guides to Hydraulic Fracturing Liners.

Secure containment is key in these operations, and even holding tanks can require liners, as well as the pad itself (the ground area of the drilling rig foundation), to offset the chance of spillage on the ground. We manufacture and install large-scale and customized liners for pits, tanks and the pad for fracking operations and standard drilling.

Regulatory and Environmental Considerations

Both drilling and fracking operations are subject to environmental regulations, which can vary significantly by region. Many regions require stringent monitoring of groundwater and the use of spill prevention controls. These regulations often dictate the standards for fluid containment, the treatment and disposal of waste fluids, and the measures required to prevent contamination of soil and groundwater.

While both standard drilling and fracking are effective methods for hydrocarbon extraction, they employ markedly different techniques and face unique challenges in fluid management and containment. As the demand for energy continues and technologies evolve, the development of more efficient and environmentally friendly containment methods remains a critical area of focus for the industry.

Back to All Articles

Get a Free Liner Quote!

Custom Fabrication on jobs
over 10,000 square feet
On-site Installation
One-Piece Liners Up To
150,000 Square Feet
Up To 20 Years Warranty &
Over 30 Years Experience